Ireland

Research Paper: Geomechanics of heave

Fred Shrimer (Golder Associates, Vancouver, Canada) has published a paper on the geomechanics of heave due to pyrite oxidation.

The paper, titled “Geomechanics of heave due the use of pyritic mudstone, Ireland” follows previous presentations and publications by Shrimer:

Shrimer, F.H., and Briggs, A. (2014). Pyritic heave in Ireland: A case study in selection. Paper presented at the 67th Canadian Geotechnical Conference (GeoRegina 2014). Saskatchewan, Canada, September 28th-October 1st 2014. Link to full paper PDF (permission granted by Fred Shrimer to upload PDF).

Shrimer, F.H., and Bromley, A.V. (2012). Pyritic heave in Ireland: The role of petrography.… Read the rest

Pyrite Resolution Board Statistics: Fourth Update

Pyrite Resolution Board Statistics

The Pyrite Resolution Board (PRB) has produced eight reports since the Pyrite Remediation Scheme was introduced in February 2014. Statistics are provided on the PRB website and in recent news articles. See statistics below and follow links for original data.

Statistics as of 14th July 2016:

  • 1248 received applications
  • 161 applications at Validation stage
  • 77 applications at Verification stage
  • 597 dwellings included in the scheme
  • 358 dwelling remediated
  • 55 applications refused

_____________________________________________________________________________________

Statistics reporting in the eighth quarterly report of the PRB:

26th February 2014 to 4th January 2016:

  • 995 completed applications
  • 37 developments containing multiple applications
  • 63 single site applications
  • 809 Validated applications
  • 744 applications included in scheme
  • 163 dwellings completed remediation
  • Works contracts in place for 184 dwellings
  • Tendering underway for 104 dwellings
  • Remedial Works Plans under preparation for 246 dwellings
  • 17 applications refused
  • No outstanding appeals
  • PRB received a total of €484,000 from liable parties in 2015

Statistics reporting in the seventh quarterly report of the PRB:

26th February 2014 to 2nd October 2015:

 

  • 887 completed applications
  • 33 developments containing multiple applications
  • 55 single site applications
  • 729 Validated applications
  • 660 applications included in scheme
  • 98 dwellings completed remediation
  • Works contracts in place for 108 dwellings
  • Tendering underway for 8 projects (219 dwellings)
  • Remedial Works Plans under preparation for 3 projects (75 dwellings)
  • 12 applications refused
  • 1 appeal decision pending

 


Statistics reported in the sixth quarterly report of the PRB:

26th February 2014 to 3th June 2015:

  • 763 completed applications
  • 33 developments containing multiple applications
  • 49 single site applications
  • 637 Validated applications
  • 520 applications included in scheme
  • Pilot project of 5 dwellings remediated (September to November 2014)
  • 16 dwellings completed remediation in 2015
  • Works contracts in place for 132 dwellings
  • Tendering underway for 65 dwellings
  • Remedial Works Plans under preparation for 163 dwellings
  • Anticipated 236 dwellings to be remediated in 2015
  • 11 dwellings refused from scheme (five have appealed)
  • In 5 cases, agreement has reached with builders/developers regarding contribution towards cost of remediation of 67 dwellings

Statistics reported by the Pyrite Resolution Board for 7th June 2015:

  • Total 763 applications (significant pyritic damage)
  • 115 applications in Validation Stage
  • 117 applications at Verification Stage
  • 520 applications included in the scheme
  • 8 applications refused

Statistics reported by the Pyrite Resolution Board for 1st May 2015:

  • Total 712 applications (significant pyritic damage)
  • 107 applications in Validation Stage
  • 97 applications at Verification Stage
  • 508 applications included in the scheme
  • 7 applications refused

Statistics reported in the fifth quarterly report of the PRB:

26th February 2014 to 31st March 2015:

  • 697 completed applications
  • 33 developments containing multiple applications
  • 49 single site applications
  • 583 Validated applications
  • 496 applications included in scheme
  • Pilot project of 5 dwellings remediated (September to November 2014)
  • Remediation of 20 dwellings commenced in February 2015
  • Contractors appointed to 72 dwellings in March 2015
  • Testing underway for 63 dwellings
  • Remedial Works Plans under preparation for 179 dwellings
  • 11 dwellings refused from scheme (three have appealed)

Statistics reported in the fourth quarterly report of the PRB:

26th February 2014 to 1st January 2015:

  • 622 completed applications
  • 27 developments containing multiple applications
  • 47 single site applications
  • 483 Validated applications
  • 321 applications included in scheme
  • Average 3 applications per week since 3rd quarterly report
  • 2 appeals in process
  • Pilot project of 5 dwellings remediated (September to November 2014)

The Irish Independent reported an update on the Pyrite Remediation Scheme statistics for the end of January 2015:

  • Total 632 applications
  • 485 applications Validated
  • 328 applications included in scheme
  • Work at tender stage for 73 dwellings
  • Work completed on 5 dwellings

Statistics reported by the Pyrite Resolution Board for 31st October 2014:

  • Total 590 applications
  • 151 applications in Validation Stage
  • 231 applications at Verification Stage
  • 208 applications included in the scheme

Statistics reported by the Pyrite Resolution Board for 7th October 2014:

  • Total 575 completed applications and 36 commenced applications
  • 144 applications in Validation Stage
  • 220 applications in Verification Stage
  • 2 Verified applications awaiting decision
  • 206 applications included in the scheme
  • Remediation contracts in place for 5 dwellings
  • 3 applications not considered

Statistics reported by the Pyrite Resolution Board for 4th July 2014:

  • Total 521 completed applications and 35 commenced applications
  • 312 applications in Validation Stage
  • 127 applications in Verification Stage
  • 27 Verified applications awaiting decision
  • 52 applications included in the scheme
  • 3 applications not considered

Statistics reported by the Pyrite Resolution Board for 15th April 2014:
  • 418 completed applications and 146 commenced applications
  • 84 applications Validated and referred to Verification Stage
Read the rest

Pyrite Resolution Board Statistics: Third Update

Pyrite Resolution Board Statistics

The Pyrite Resolution Board (PRB) has produced eight reports since the Pyrite Remediation Scheme was introduced in February 2014. Further statistics are provided on the PRB website and in recent news articles. See statistics below and follow links for original data.

Statistics reporting in the eighth quarterly report of the PRB:

26th February 2014 to 4th January 2016:

  • 995 completed applications
  • 37 developments containing multiple applications
  • 63 single site applications
  • 809 Validated applications
  • 744 applications included in scheme
  • 163 dwellings completed remediation
  • Works contractors in place for 184 dwellings
  • Tendering underway for 104 dwellings
  • Remedial Works Plans under preparation for 246 dwellings
  • 17 applications refused
  • No outstanding appeals
  • PRB received a total of €484,000 from liable parties in 2015

 

Statistics reporting in the seventh quarterly report of the PRB:

Report not available on the PRB website.… Read the rest

European Court gives opinion in James Elliott case

European court of justice opinion delivered

The Advocate General of the European Court of Justice, Campos Sanchez-Bordona has delivered an opinion on Case C-613/14 (James Elliott Construction Ltd v Irish Asphalt Ltd). The Opinion was given in response to the request for a preliminary ruling from the Supreme Court of Ireland. The Opinion was delivered on 28/01/2016. The full text of the Opinion and the conclusions can be read by clicking here.

Interpretation and implications

An excellent summary of the James Elliott Construction Ltd v Irish Asphalt Ltd case can be found here on the EU Law Radar website.… Read the rest

Research Paper: Evaluating pyrite-induced swelling

George Matheson (Matrock Consulting) and Paul Quigley (Irish Geotechnical Services Ltd) have published a paper on the petrological examination and assessment of aggregates that have undergone pyrite-induced swelling.

The paper, titled “Evaluating pyrite-induced swelling in Dublin mudrocks” follows previous presentations and publications by the Matheson:

Matheson, G.D, and Jones, G.L.I. (2015). The habit and form of gypsum crystals in Irish mudstone aggregate affected by pyrite-induced swelling. Quarterly Journal of Engineering Geology and Hydrogeology. 48, 167-174. Click here to read a summary of the paper.

Matheson, G. (2012). Pyrite-induced swelling. Annual Guest Lecture given to the Geotechnical Society of Ireland.… Read the rest

Research Paper: Gypsum crystals in Irish mudstone aggregate

George Matheson (Matrock Consulting) and Gareth Jones (Conodate Geology) have published a paper on the mineralogy of gypsum in aggregates that have undergone pyrite heave. The authors used advanced petrography to examine the form of gypsum and its relation to forceful or passive growth with regards to aggregate expansion.

The paper, titled “The habit and form of gypsum crystals in Irish mudstone aggregate affected by pyrite-induced swelling” follows previous presentations by Matheson, e.g., in December 2012:

Matheson, G. (2012). Pyrite-induced swelling. Annual Guest Lecture given to the Geotechnical Society of Ireland. 6.12.12, Engineers Ireland, Dublin. Click here to see original flyer.Read the rest

Research Paper: Investigation of pyrite heave in Dublin, Ireland

Pyrite Heave in Dublin

Mourice Czerewko (AECOM) and John Cripps (University of Sheffield) have published a paper on the investigation of pyrite heave affecting properties in Dublin, Ireland. The authors report on a case study from north Dublin, where pyrite bearing fill had been used below the new-build property floor slabs.

The paper, titled “Investigation of destructive ground heave affecting new-build properties constructed using pyrite bearing fill in the Dublin area of Ireland” follows prior research on the Irish pyrite problems (click here to view literature on the Irish pyrite issues).

Abstract

“Although structural damage caused by the expansion of bedrock and fills due to the presence of pyrite has been documented internationally since the 1960s, there is an apparent lack of awareness of the potential for these problems in the construction industry, particularly the domestic housing sector.
Read the rest

Ireland: Second Update on Pyrite Resolution Board Statistics

Pyrite Resolution Board STATISTICS

The Pyrite Resolution Board (PRB) has produced six reports since the Pyrite Remediation Scheme was introduced in February 2014. Further statistics are provided on the PRB website and in recent news articles. See statistics below and follow links for original data.

Pyrite Resolution Board Statistics reported in the sixth quarterly report of the PRB:

26th February 2014 to 3th June 2015:

  • 763 completed applications
  • 33 developments containing multiple applications
  • 49 single site applications
  • 637 Validated applications
  • 520 applications included in scheme
  • Pilot project of 5 dwellings remediated (September to November 2014)
  • 16 dwellings completed remediation in 2015
  • Works contractors in place for 132 dwellings
  • Tendering underway for 65 dwellings
  • Remedial Works Plans under preparation for 163 dwellings
  • Anticipated 236 dwellings to be remediated in 2015
  • 11 dwellings refused from scheme (five have appealed)
  • In 5 cases, agreement has reached with builders/developers regarding contribution towards cost of remediation of 67 dwellings

Pyrite Resolution Board Statistics reported by the Pyrite Resolution Board for 7th June 2015:

  • Total 763 applications (significant pyritic damage)
  • 115 applications in Validation Stage
  • 117 applications at Verification Stage
  • 520 applications included in the scheme
  • 8 applications refused

Pyrite Resolution Board Statistics reported by the Pyrite Resolution Board for 1st May 2015:

  • Total 712 applications (significant pyritic damage)
  • 107 applications in Validation Stage
  • 97 applications at Verification Stage
  • 508 applications included in the scheme
  • 7 applications refused

Pyrite Resolution Board Statistics reported in the fifth quarterly report of the PRB:

26th February 2014 to 31st March 2015:

  • 697 completed applications
  • 33 developments containing multiple applications
  • 49 single site applications
  • 583 Validated applications
  • 496 applications included in scheme
  • Pilot project of 5 dwellings remediated (September to November 2014)
  • Remediation of 20 dwellings commenced in February 2015
  • Contractors appointed to 72 dwellings in March 2015
  • Testing underway for 63 dwellings
  • Remedial Works Plans under preparation for 179 dwellings
  • 11 dwellings refused from scheme (three have appealed)

Pyrite Resolution Board Statistics reported in the fourth quarterly report of the PRB:

26th February 2014 to 1st January 2015:

  • 622 completed applications
  • 27 developments containing multiple applications
  • 47 single site applications
  • 483 Validated applications
  • 321 applications included in scheme
  • Average 3 applications per week since 3rd quarterly report
  • 2 appeals in process
  • Pilot project of 5 dwellings remediated (September to November 2014)

The Irish Independent reported an update on the Pyrite Remediation Scheme statistics for the end of January 2015:

  • Total 632 applications
  • 485 applications Validated
  • 328 applications included in scheme
  • Work at tender stage for 73 dwellings
  • Work completed on 5 dwellings

Pyrite Resolution Board Statistics reported by the Pyrite Resolution Board for 31st October 2014:

  • Total 590 applications
  • 151 applications in Validation Stage
  • 231 applications at Verification Stage
  • 208 applications included in the scheme

Pyrite Resolution Board Statistics reported by the Pyrite Resolution Board for 7th October 2014:

  • Total 575 completed applications and 36 commenced applications
  • 144 applications in Validation Stage
  • 220 applications in Verification Stage
  • 2 Verified applications awaiting decision
  • 206 applications included in the scheme
  • Remediation contracts in place for 5 dwellings
  • 3 applications not considered

Pyrite Resolution Board Statistics reported by the Pyrite Resolution Board for 4th July 2014:

  • Total 521 completed applications and 35 commenced applications
  • 312 applications in Validation Stage
  • 127 applications in Verification Stage
  • 27 Verified applications awaiting decision
  • 52 applications included in the scheme
  • 3 applications not considered
Pyrite Resolution Board Statistics reported by the Pyrite Resolution Board for 15th April 2014:
  • 418 completed applications and 146 commenced applications
  • 84 applications Validated and referred to Verification Stage
Read the rest

HomeBond’s Repudiation of Purchasers’ Claims

Homebond’s repudiation of purchasers’ claims – was it lawful?

Joseph Tyrrell (FCII, FCILA, FUEDI-ELAE), an insurance claims expert from Dublin, has published an extensive report on HomeBond’s repudiation of purchasers’ claims under the Major Defects Warranty in the HomeBond Agreement for Damage by Pyritic Heave.

report executive summary

In the report summary, Joseph Tyrrell writes:

“Following a wide-ranging investigation, I am satisfied that HomeBond’s rejection of hundreds of its warranty-holders’ claims was invalid, for reasons which I have examined in detail in the main body of this report…”

“It is astonishing, to my mind, that no one in authority appears to have looked closely at the reasons given for wrongfully turning down so many Purchasers’ claims, but it seems that this is what happened and that HomeBond has thus far got away with its shameful behaviour.

Read the rest

Pyrite Resolution Board report: 2014

Pyrite Resolution Board Report 2014

The Pyrite Resolution Board report (for 2014) was published on 17th June 2015. The report PDF can be found on the Pyrite Resolution Board website, or by clicking this link.

Applications Summary (END of 2014)

The PRB first annual report provides a summary of applications to the Board. Photographs of typical damage and the remediation process are included within the report. At the end of 2014, the applications were as follows:

620 applications in total
145 applications at Validation (including 6 refused applications)
171 applications Validated, at Verification
3 applications Verified and awaiting decision on inclusion
301 applications Included in scheme
106 applications in Planning/Scheduling
190 applications at Specification and Tender Preparation stage
0 applications in Remediation
5 applications Remediated

expenditure

The total expenditure reported for 2014 was reported as €796,969, with the following breakdown:
IT System Setup €72,320
Engineers €145,380 (€306,722 outstanding at end of 2014)
Works Contractors €144,371 (€3,701 outstanding at end of 2014)
Homeowner’s Payments €142,756
Administration & Overheads €292,142
The above can also be considered in terms of proportions of the whole expenditure (own calculations, not those of the PRB):
IT System Setup (9 %)
Engineers (18 %)
Works Contractors (18 %)
Homeowner’s Payments (18 %)
Administration & Overheads (37 %)
An additional €1,663,224 is possible for future payments “…in respect of the 301 dwellings included in the Scheme in 2014 for the Building Condition Assessment, alternative accommodation and storage…”

legal proceedings

The PRB report states that “…legal proceedings by the PRB against a developer in respect of 17 dwellings have commenced and it is anticipated that others will follow.Read the rest